Skip to main content

Craft Commerce vs Shopify: Costs, Control and When a Custom Shop Beats Both

In this article

Craft Commerce and Shopify sit at opposite ends of the same decision. Shopify is a hosted platform: you rent the shop, Shopify runs it, and you pay a plan and a share of each card payment for as long as you trade. Craft Commerce is software you license once and host yourself, built on the Craft content management system, so you own the build and pay no platform cut, but you need a developer to make it and keep it running.

A custom shop takes that one step further: nothing licensed, nothing rented, everything written for how you sell. This comparison puts the three side by side on cost, control and the kind of shop each one suits, with prices as published on 20 November 2026.

The short answer

  • Choose Shopify if you sell standard products with simple pricing, want to launch quickly and would rather pay monthly than commission a build. It is quick, reliable and cheap to start.
  • Choose Craft Commerce if content is as important as the catalogue, you want to own and host the shop, and you have a developer who knows Craft. You pay for licences and development instead of a plan and transaction fees.
  • Choose a custom shop when the way you sell does not fit either: made-to-order products, trade price lists, unusual postage rules, deep integrations, or a shop inside a larger platform.
  • Do not switch to save on fees alone. For a straightforward shop the fees are close; the case for owning the shop rests on what it has to do.

What you are actually comparing

Shopify is a hosted ecommerce platform. The catalogue, checkout and admin are Shopify's, customised through themes and apps. You never touch a server, and in return you work within Shopify's model: fixed URL structures, a checkout you can only fully customise on Plus, and an app for anything the core does not do.

Craft Commerce is an ecommerce plugin for Craft CMS, a content management system that developers build sites on. You buy a licence, host it where you like (or on Craft's own cloud), and a developer builds the storefront, templates and any integrations. Craft's pages list unlimited products and variants, a custom checkout flow, multi-currency, catalogue pricing and discounts, up to five stores and five inventory locations, and first-party payment integrations for Stripe, PayPal Checkout and Mollie.

A custom shop is written for your business in a framework such as Django. There is no platform underneath and no licence: the catalogue, pricing rules, checkout and admin are built around how you sell, and once the project is paid for the code is yours.

What each one costs

Prices as shown on the platforms' own pricing pages on 20 November 2026. Craft's prices are listed in dollars with no UK or VAT detail; Shopify's UK page is in pounds.

ShopifyCraft CommerceCustom shop
To startYour time, or roughly £2,000 to £10,000 for an agency set-upCommerce Pro licence $1,199 per project, plus a Craft CMS licence (Pro $399 per project), plus the developer's buildRoughly £5,000 to £30,000 across the UK market; our own shops are a rough £5,000 to £12,000
Every monthBasic £25, Grow £65, Advanced £344, Plus from £1,800 (less billed yearly: £19, £49, £259), plus appsHosting, and a developer for changesHosting, and maintenance if you want someone to look after it
Every yearNothing extraUpdates after the first year: $299 for Commerce and $99 for Craft CMSNothing extra
On each saleCard rate on Shopify Payments from 2% + 25p (Basic) to 1.5% + 25p (Advanced); a transaction fee of 2% down to 0.6% if you use another payment providerYour payment provider's own fee, with no platform fee mentioned on Craft's pricing pagesYour payment provider's own fee: Stripe's standard UK card rate was 1.5% + 20p in September 2026

The pattern is the same as in our Shopify vs custom comparison: Shopify is cheapest to start and dearest to run, and the other two reverse that. For a shop turning over £250,000 a year, the yearly fees on Shopify's main plans came to about £6,100 to £8,100 in that comparison, against about £4,750 plus hosting and maintenance on a shop with Stripe. Craft sits with the second group on fees, with licence renewals on top. Put your own figures into our free Shopify vs custom calculator for a one, three and five year view.

Control: what you can change and what you own

Checkout. On Shopify, full checkout customisation is a Plus feature. Craft Commerce lists a custom checkout flow in its Pro edition. A custom shop's checkout is whatever you need it to be, which matters for deposits, booking dates, trade approval steps or conditional delivery.

Pricing and catalogue. Shopify's B2B tools are capped at three catalogues below Plus. Craft lists catalogue pricing and discounts and multi-currency per store. A custom build models price lists per customer, volume tiers, minimum order quantities and quote-to-order flows directly.

Data and ownership. On Shopify your data lives on Shopify, and customer passwords do not export if you leave. With Craft you host the database and own the build, under a licence. With a custom shop you own the code, the database and every account outright.

Content. This is Craft's strength. Its content tools are the reason people choose it over Shopify for shops where editorial pages, guides and campaigns matter as much as products. A custom shop can have the same, but it is built rather than included.

Where each one fits

Shopify fits standard retail: a catalogue of products with fixed prices, normal delivery and no unusual integrations. If a few well-supported apps cover what you need, it is the right call and we say so.

Craft Commerce fits a content-led shop with a Craft developer on hand: a brand with a lot to say around its products, selling in more than one currency or through more than one store, that wants to own and host the result.

A custom shop fits the business whose selling rules are the business: made-to-order products, trade pricing, postage worked out by weight and zone, stock in several places, or a shop that is one part of a bigger platform. Our guide to planning a custom ecommerce website is the checklist for that case, and our custom ecommerce websites are built from it.

Moving from one to another

Any move between the three is the same job: export products, customers and order history, map every old product, collection and page URL to its new address and set up 301 redirects before launch, keep the titles and product copy that already rank, and plan a password reset email for customers. Craft and a custom shop both let you keep your URL structure, which Shopify's fixed prefixes do not.

Questions people ask

Is Craft Commerce cheaper than Shopify?

To run, usually: there is no plan and no platform transaction fee, only hosting, licence renewals of $299 a year for Commerce and $99 for Craft CMS, and developer time. To start, no: the licences are $1,199 and $399 per project before any build, against a Shopify plan from £19 a month. Over three years the answer depends on your sales volume, how many Shopify apps you would otherwise pay for, and how often you change the shop.

Does Craft Commerce charge transaction fees?

Its pricing pages do not mention a transaction fee or a share of revenue. You pay your payment provider's own rate, through Craft's first-party Stripe, PayPal Checkout or Mollie integrations. Shopify, by contrast, adds a fee of 2% down to 0.6% when you use a payment provider other than Shopify Payments.

Do I need a developer for Craft Commerce?

Yes. Craft is a content management system that a developer builds a site on, and Commerce is a plugin for it; there is no themed storefront to switch on. Budget for a developer to build the shop and to keep Craft, the plugin and the hosting up to date, as you would for any self-hosted platform. If you would rather someone else ran the shop, our Shopify vs EKM comparison covers the managed route.

When is a custom shop better than both?

When the shop has to do things neither platform models well: prices calculated from dimensions or materials, trade accounts with their own terms, unusual postage rules, stock across locations, deep links to your own systems, or a shop that is one step in a larger service. Then the build is priced on those rules, and nothing is rented or licensed afterwards.

Where to start

Write down the three selling rules that are most awkward today and test each option against them: can Shopify do it without an app, can Craft do it with a developer, and would a custom build do it as a matter of course? If you would like a second opinion on the answers, book a free 30-minute call and we will tell you which route we would take, including when that is Shopify.